Connect with us

Elementary

Elementary – On the Scent (7×09)

"On the Scent" - Holmes and Watson work to determine if a long dormant serial killer has resurfaced in the wake of a sculptor's murder in New York City. Also, Watson suspects Holmes is keeping something from her regarding tech billionaire Odin Reichenbach, on the 150th episode of ELEMENTARY, Thursday, July 18 (10:00-11:00, ET/PT), on the CBS Television Network. Pictured (L-R) Jon Michael Hill as Detective Marcus Bell, Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock Holmes, Aidan Quinn as Captain Tommy Gregson and Lucy Liu as Joan Watson Photo: Jeff Neira/CBS ©2018 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Published

on

Joan is FINALLY let in on the Reichenbach/McNally situation. In retrospect, I feel that Watson being kept in the dark may have been a clever way for the writers to delay the progress of this storyline. Watson’s lack of agency in the situation may have allowed the writer’s to have a few weeks to tell more procedural based stories and take the time to bring Sherlock’s character arc to a fitting resting point in last week’s “Miss Understood.”

Now that we are in the back third of the season, though, it’s time to ramp the serialized plot up again and bringing Joan into the loop is the perfect way to do this. Just as she says to Sherlock, she isn’t willing to just roll over, which suggests to me that Watson will have agency in this final story line, and the partners will take initiative to topple Reichenbach.

It’s always more fun to have Sherlock and Watson on the same page, so I’m glad he clued her in and agreed not to keep anything further from her. It was only a matter of time until he did tell her, and part of me feels Sherlock leaves those McNally papers so shoddily hidden in hopes that Watson will find them and confront him. He wants to tell her, but also wants to save her from the “corrosive” nature keeping the secret entails. Allowing her to find out on her own lets him do both. Or maybe I’m looking too deep into it.

More telling, though, is that Watson has learned that when Sherlock lies he has a tell. It’s never revealed exactly what this tell is, but nobody knows Sherlock better than Watson does. As she states, no one else can notice when he lies, and this moment shows us just how close these two are and reminds us how far they have come.

Regarding Reichenbach, I still wish we had more time to get to know him. It’s interesting because he isn’t a straight villain, as he does believe he is doing what’s best for the world. The most compelling villains often do believe they are the good guy, but we haven’t seen quite enough of Reichenbach yet for me to see or feel how his actions are affecting him. Does he get satisfaction from murdering people, or just from believing he is saving lives? Does he care that he may be making mistakes, or is he just not willing to risk letting someone live? The final scene this week tells us what Reichenbach is going to do, but we don’t really see the man behind these decisions. Hopefully this character comes to life in the next few weeks – I’m assuming he will have his chance to since we are coming upon the finale.

The case this week started at point A and ended at number 10. Until typing this sentence, I had completely forgotten that this episode starts with the team chasing a serial killer. If a mystery can take me that far away from the original premise and still make sense, I think that’s a good sign. I like how inelegant the reveal for “The Ghost” is. How incredibly frustrating must it be for police officers to be chasing a serial killer and then find out it was just some random worker messing up their DNA tests? Serial killers are top priority situations and the reality here is just so mundane. It just goes to show the mud detectives have to slop through to put together a reasonable case.

Joan also makes a huge contribution this week with her sports awareness when she discovers the shipment system. But even before her show of this more specialized knowledge, Joan was detecting left, right, and all over the place. The episode starts with her investing a Reichenbach hit on her own, and during the Gibbs case she provides many insights with no influence from Sherlock (such as the killer likely being of the same body type as Gibbs). Joan has been an above average detective for a while now, but with the growth that Sherlock proved last week, her independence in this episode further emphasizes that these two no longer need to work together; instead they are choosing to work together. There is no greater compliment two individuals can pay to a partnership.

If only I could choose to watch this show for a season 8.

Other Deductions:

  • I need to pay special notice to the reveal of the murderer during the murder scene. Music is imperative when it comes to tone, and the lack of a stinger (a musical cue to emphasize a visual action or reveal) when the camera reveals the killer makes this scene entirely more creepy than it needs to be. The score just continues as normal, which makes the reveal seem unsettlingly casual. With no music cue emphasizing the event it makes us feel like the show is accepting this scene as normal; as if nothing odd was happening at all. Since we as the audience know that this is definitely NOT normal, it increases the creep factor because something is “off.” The lack of stinger provides this juxtaposition, and I love the creative choice here. (This works the same way as playing a children’s nursery rhyme in a dark creepy horror movie does. It just doesn’t “fit” in our preconceived notion of what scary is supposed to be, providing an extra discomfort).
  • Sherlock has consistently trusted people’s first instincts throughout this series. There is an episode in season one where Sherlock encourages Watson to trust her first instinct about a medical condition a young soccer player has, and he explains how first instincts are often correct. It is great consistency that he also trusts Mr. Hutchins’ first instinct that his son-in-law killed his daughter.
  • Bell was so annoyed that he had to arrest Fowler for stealing phones. He got to arrest him for murder in the end, though.
  • Four to go! I’m most looking forward to Sherlock ruining McNally. Hopefully Reichenbach makes me root for his own demise just as hard!

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Elementary

Elementary – Their Last Bow (7×13)

Published

on

Elementary-TheirLastBow

“I’m pretty sure you’re going to live forever.”

Watson speaks of the immortality of the world’s greatest detective in the final entry of Elementary, the umpteenth adaptation of Sherlock Holmes since his creation well over 100 years ago. Sherlock Holmes, the character, will likely exist in one form or another for as long as storytelling exists. He was resurrected from his initial death by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and has been resurrected countless times since.

Our version of the great detective was resurrected tonight to grace our screen in this form for one last bow.

The episode begins with a three year jump to the future. This isn’t an uncommon technique for final episodes to take when wrapping up a series. While not wholly original, it’s an affective way to provide a slow down from a climax and still provide some tension.

Television finales can be difficult compared to film endings because a film has the luxury of proper pacing. Normally when a story reaches its climax, there is a denouement to wrap up the lingering storylines and character beats. The climax of a film normally happens about 10-20 minutes before the end of the film, with the last scenes being of slower pace and less action.

Television gets wonky because normally there is so much happening near the end of a show that 10-20 minutes isn’t quite enough to wrap everything up neatly, so often times the climax of a series will happen a few episodes before the ending (such as Breaking Bad’s “Ozymandias”), with Elementary having its climax on the bridge in the previous episode “Reichenbach Falls.” However, if a series has an entire episode of denouement, that doesn’t make for the most exciting block of television.

The time jump solves this issue by providing us enough new material to excite us while still allowing us to resolve lingering character conflicts, such as Sherlock’s faking of his death and the limbo he left his friendships in and Reichenbach’s sentencing. Reichenbach is wrapped up immediately and the focus shifts to Watson’s new life and the return of her partner.

Sherlock’s return was an obvious callback to their first meeting – but you just HAVE to do stuff like this in a finale, no? It feels so good when a story comes full circle, and imagery like Sherlock watching all his televisions is the perfect image to bring us back to the start of the series.

His commitment to Watson, however, is entirely different than it was at the start. He shows up just hours after Watson calls for him (by smashing his grave! Very symbolic and very Sherlock), despite the long absence of communication and with zero regards to the risks it poses.

Their reunion is understated and normal to the point that I almost felt they had seen each other regularly, which only further speaks to their bond. Watson may have been angry Sherlock stopped communicating (angry enough to write a book about him, which was another great callback to the original tales), but she knows him and understands him, and knows that he is there for her despite falling out of touch.

Bell, on the other hand, punches him in the stomach. Bell has done a lot for Sherlock and considered him one of their own, and between Gregson, Watson, and Bell, Bell is the most “friend” like of the group. Gregson is more of a father figure, tough and understanding, and Watson is Sherlock’s heart and soul. But Bell is just a friend. This is not an insult, but in fact a compliment, since Sherlock doesn’t have ANY other people in his life who are “just” friends. Because their relationship is based in friendship, I believe Bell took Sherlock’s fake out more personally. He still smiled before he punched him, though; they’ll be working together again soon enough. We’ve seen enough ups and downs between the two to know it, and so has Bell. Bell’s grudge is proven to be minor when he asks Joan if she’s going to tell Sherlock about her cancer. He clearly still has an interest in Sherlock’s feelings.

Gregson’s meet up is much friendlier, and was probably my favorite scene of the hour. As I stated earlier, Gregson is somewhat of a father figure for Sherlock, and the guidance and trust shown here is the perfect place to leave their relationship. Gregson wants what’s best for Sherlock and what’s best for Watson. He knows that Watson will make the decisions best for her, but Sherlock…he needs a push sometimes. Gregson compares Sherlock and Watson’s relationship to his relationship with his wife.

They discuss love, but it is clear that it is never in the context of romance (though if you want to read it that way, as I’m sure some people do, I can’t stop you. Enjoy it!). Gregson knows first hand that Sherlock loves Watson unlike anyone Sherlock has ever known. At the end of season six, Sherlock is willing to go against the captain for Watson. It’s a powerful argument between the two and its made clear that Sherlock will do anything for her. Gregson tells him that when you feel that way about someone, you need to let them choose. Give Watson the choice whether or not Sherlock stays.

Sherlock has also come to a place with the captain where he can reveal that he relapsed after he went into hiding. I was curious as to whether or not Sherlock’s addiction would come up tonight, and I’m glad it did. The fact of the matter is that Sherlock will never not be an addict, and his fear of staying with Watson and having her son find him dead with a needle in his arm is a real fear that understandably would keep Sherlock away. As awful a scene as that would be, I’m glad they gave us an image of it. Addiction isn’t something to brush aside and I feel that if they didn’t give this moment this sort of heft it would have felt glossed over. Of course, Gregson responds by telling Sherlock about Joan’s diagnosis.

I have in my notes, “Not Watson’s grave.” You can’t fool me, Elementary. They tried that twice this year! Twice! What is it with the writers and these fake deathssssss oh man what if they were purposeful foreshadowing of Sherlock’s fake death??? I just thought of that while writing this but I’m leaving it in as is because that would be really clever if that was what was intended. Anyway, back to the Watson fake out.

I have in my notes, “Not Watson’s grave.” I didn’t believe that Elementary would tear its duo apart so cruelly, as it would also have gone against Gregson’s message about choice. Who we spend time with is a choice. What we are willing to put up with from those people is a choice. And what we do in life, be it adopt a child or fighting super crime in Europe, is a choice.

Over and over again throughout Elementary we have seen Sherlock and Watson make decisions. For Watson, she first chose to stay with Sherlock after her companionship ended. In season three Watson chose to move back in with Sherlock, and in season four it was Watson’s decision to stick with Sherlock after his NYPD suspension. Sherlock’s choices, however, often pushed him away from Watson. He chose to work for MI6 at the end of season two, and fled to London at the end of season six (with Watson once again keeping the partnership alive but following). Tonight it was Sherlock’s turn to choose to stay, and of course he stayed. I believe that was the first time Sherlock initiated a hug since Irene. It’s a powerful embrace not just due to the scarcity but the genuine emotion that is outwardly flowing through Sherlock. And Watson, who is as stone cold as they come, is actually scared, and for once she’s the one in need of comfort. Sherlock chooses to provide that for her.

The more meaningful choice in our story, though, is the one at the episode’s close. The decision for Sherlock to stay during Watson’s trials is one of support, but at the close, Sherlock denies McNally’s offering of an NSA position and goes back to Watson, who is now fully healthy. For the first time in the series, both characters are in a place of individual happiness and yet they choose to be together anyway. That is a true partnership. They may have been brought together through circumstance, and stayed together through tragedy, but they ended up together because they wanted to.

Sherlock Holmes made a bond. He created a family unit. He worked hard to become a better person and works hard to stay sober. He deserves some happiness now, and I’m glad he’s choosing to have it. His early days of punishing himself by not playing the violin are over. It’s time to embrace what he has earned in his life.

As an ending to the plot, there really wasn’t one. Sherlock and Watson will continue solving crimes as consulting detectives in New York. Bell will be the captain, and they’ll go have tea with Gregson sometimes. I wish we could watch that.

As an ending to our story, I really liked this. For the first time there is an air of peace floating around these characters, and if our story was about these two people coming together, this closes that story. They made their final choice here. In the end, they created a partnership that will last a lifetime.

But for us, that means we no longer get to see them work together. Elementary’s version of these characters was unique. Watson was more intelligent and able than I’ve ever seen, and Sherlock was more human, and dare I say more complex, than ever. Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson will be back in some form of adaptation some day. They will solve mysteries. Sherlock will be a brilliant detective and Watson will be his sturdy hand, but it will be a while before we see another partnership as deep as the one we witnessed flourish the last seven years.

Elementary is over, but I’m pretty sure Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson will live forever.

Other Deductions:

  • I didn’t even mention Moriarty in this review because she was sort of a side note here. I was pretty pumped when her name was mentioned, and then kind of bummed when she was a misdirect, but then when Gregson pointed out Sherlock’s love for Watson, it felt ok to me. Moriarty is in Sherlock’s past, and he doesn’t treat her as the singular mind he used to, so why should the show? Watson is much more important to Sherlock now, and I’m not sad that Moriarty didn’t reappear or pose a threat one last time.
  • Sherlock was peeved over Watson’s book on him and she knew he would be. What a beautiful relationship.
  • Watson fixed up the brownstone so nice and it just made me think how much thought she definitely put into these changes over seven years of living there. I doubt Sherlock was gone for more than a month before she put some carpet in.
  • Watson got softer in Sherlock’s absence and his manners took a dive. They absolutely influence each other and make each other stronger individuals, but I like that neither fell apart without the other (Sherlock’s relapse and near death is of course an exception, but after this he had what is assumed to be four years of sobriety and seemed well).
  • McNally. I don’t know what to think of him. He was decently likable until he was working with Reichenbach, and he felt like his old likable self here. His offer would have felt more genuine if he didn’t lose my trust this year. Still a pretty cool offer, though.
  • Sherlock meeting Arthur and saying it is truly an honor. Sherlock loves this kid because he is Watson’s child.
  • “As long as we’re together, what does it matter?” I put a condition on this, Sherlock! It doesn’t matter how Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are together if they are treated with care and painted as full people, as they were in Elementary. Be they gender swapped, given different backgrounds, or even if they are fish (Sharklock Holmes and Dr. Watsfin!), Elementary proved that it didn’t matter, a great partnership, and great Sherlock adaption, can be made in many ways.

I find it difficult to recap television finales in the immediate moments after they air because finales wrap up not just a season, but the entire series, and a reflection on a show that aired for seven years deserves more reflection than possible at the current moment. Though my particular opinions on the finale may change over the coming days or weeks, I know that I will continue to see Elementary and its lead duo as a great success amongst Sherlock Holmes adaptations, and I will truly miss it.

Continue Reading

Elementary

Elementary – Reichenbach Falls (7×12)

Published

on

Elementary-ReichenbachFalls

“I’m the only Holmes left now.”

This line uttered by Sherlock in the back half of the penultimate hour of Elementary may have been the first time he ever showed any sentiment towards his family’s name. He was never close with his father or brother, and while his relationship with his mother was better, I don’t feel he considered her a “Holmes” in the same way as his brother and father. Sherlock considers what it means to be the last member of his bloodline here, and I sensed almost a responsibility in his voice.

What will the Holmes name mean moving forward? Sherlock alone gets to decide this. And he chooses to abandon it, because as he knows, a person’s actions are more important than their name. He sacrifices his identity to stop a mass murderer. At the close of “Reichenbach Falls” the Holmes name is dead.

The name of Reichenbach, however, will be dragged through the mud, as Gregson promised. Reichenbach never feared the Holmes’. He arrogantly continued his operations immediately after the investigation into him hit a dead end. He was too powerful and too careful. There was no evidence that could bring him down.

I really enjoyed that the first two-thirds of this episode stuck to the mystery format. Elementary is a mystery series and I feared the show would abandon its premise to focus on the overarching story, and while that is obviously the focus here, we still get to see Sherlock, Watson, Bell, and Gregson do some good old fashioned police work.

Gregson’s first meeting with Reichenbach was a great example of Reichenbach’s dismissal of the law. He openly disrespected the police captain, and despite Gregson’s anger and tone, wasn’t afraid of him at all. At no point did Reichenbach feel he could actually be touched by the law. He was above it.

It was heartwarming to see the captain stand up for Sherlock, but we knew that already. That isn’t a complaint – I want to see these bonds be proven again before the end of the series. Gregson and Sherlock don’t share a perfect past, but Gregson trusts Sherlock completely, and that trust, that bond, is what makes Gregson a part of Sherlock’s family. Not in name, but in choice. Sherlock knows he can let his name die precisely because he knows the bonds he made with people like Gregson and Bell will keep this investigation moving and ensure his plan to ensnare Reichenbach will work.

Reichenbach’s meeting with Sherlock is of a different pace. Unlike Gregson, Sherlock doesn’t represent the law. To Reichenbach, Sherlock represents his mirror – an equal in intellect who can see the big picture the same way, despite being on different sides. As Reichenbach states, they are the same.

Except they aren’t, because what Reichenbach has failed to deduce over this past season is that at the end of the day, Sherlock is smarter than him.

It doesn’t matter how well his tracks are covered, who he has in his pocket, or how much information he controls. Sherlock Holmes is smarter than Reichenbach, and if Sherlock Holmes wants you convicted badly enough, he will find a way to convict you.

Ironically, Reichenbach speaks about Sherlock not being able to let go of the past and being unable to look forward, when it’s that exact type of thinking that allowed Sherlock to pull this off. Reichenbach was unable to see a future where his past deeds came back to haunt him. He never needed to live with his past. Sherlock, on the other hand, has had to do nothing but live with his past. It’s been the goal of his entire character arc, and his verbal realization of the idea that living with your past is what creates justice is the perfect final sentiment for him.

And so Sherlock frames Reichenbach for murder, which will dig up all of his skeletons even if this particular murder doesn’t stick. Reichenbach will have to live with his past, just as Sherlock has learned to do over the course of the series.

It’s a great message for a mystery series about putting killers behind bars. Sherlock and Watson have served justice in New York for seven years by forcing murderers to face the consequences of their actions. I never quite realized what an apt theme this is for a crime procedural and how well it is reflected in Sherlock’s journey. This is one of those statements that retroactively strengthens the entirety of the series – as Sherlock serves justice to criminals, he must also learn to atone for his own past mistakes.

Some may say that Sherlock escaping and taking a false name will allow him to forget and operate outside his past, but this isn’t the case (and never will be the case) for Sherlock. He’s a drug addict, and that will never leave him. He will carry that with him forever, no matter what his name or where he is. But he has learned to live with and accept the consequences of his behavior, allowing him to grow and become someone able to stand on his own.

Because we had seen this growth well before the climactic scene on the bridge, there was never tension for me personally as to whether or not Sherlock would shoot Reichenbach. Sherlock has grown past the need for revenge and the desire for murder, so instead the tension lied in how Sherlock was going to pull this off.

To that, we still don’t know! We have one episode left to find out. It’s finally time to say goodbye to Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Joan Watson.

Other Deductions:

  • Sherlock wasn’t close with his father but they had turned a corner over the last year. It was sad when Sherlock asked if Morland suffered. Sherlock may not have liked his father much but he did care for him, and knew that his father cared for his son.
  • Gregson grabbing Reichenbach as he tried to walk away is a good piece of emotional storytelling but also solid foreshadowing for Reichenbach’s future inability to just walk away from what he’s done.
  • Of course the climax had to take place on a bridge and of course he had to fall off of it. Can you even call yourself a Sherlock Holmes adaptation if you don’t have a scene calling back to The Final Problem?
  • Bell and Gregson better learn that Sherlock is still alive.
  • Watson and Sherlock better have the greatest Watson and Sherlock episode of all time next week. No matter how much of her there is I still will not think there was enough of her this season, but a proper display for her in the finale will go a long way in making me chill out about that a bit.
  • Season 7 has been a suitable sendoff and I’m grateful we got to spend another year with these characters. I definitely feel this season was necessary, for Sherlock reached a better ending point for his character arc.

 

One more left

Continue Reading

Elementary

Elementary – Unfriended (7×11)

Published

on

Elementary-Unfriended

Whether the Sherlock Holmes of Elementary would ever admit to it or not doesn’t matter – from the start of the first episode he has always been, for lack of a better term, a daddy’s boy. He was pushed into rehab by his father, his living space is his father’s, the sober companion hired to assist him in recovery was hired by his father, and a large amount of – if not all of – Sherlock’s day to day was provided to him by his father’s money.

Of course, Sherlock has been away from his father and making a life for himself that he calls his own, despite the major influence Morland’s money has had on that life. And in this life, Sherlock has grown. As I’ve stated in previous reviews, I feel Sherlock has grown past the need of Watson by his side, and now Sherlock will finally have to stand on his own two feet without his father’s influence.

In regards to classic storytelling, Morland’s death hits the Do Re Mi of basic story beats. The series started with Morland forcing a new life and a second chance upon his son, and is now ending with a Sherlock who is able to stand alone because of that initial push. Sherlock put in the work on his own, he’s the one who went through rehab, who continues to go to meetings, and who put the effort in to become a better human being through his relationships with Watson, Bell, and Gregson, but all of that positive progress was absolutely started because of his father. Morland may not have been as present or loving as Sherlock would have liked, and he was in no ways a perfect (or necessarily even a good) father, but between Morland’s push to New York and Sherlock’s immense amount of self improvement, they made a Sherlock Holmes who will be able to bring down Reichenbach without his father. Elementary starts with Morland’s influence and ends with the loss of it. Very full circle, gotta love it.

I was right with my thought that Reichenbach may have set up the murder last week! What a jerk. Sherlock has come too far and knows how to approach people, so his confidence in himself was not misplaced. His growth in this sense is once again on display later in the episode. When Sherlock first goes to speak with Annie, the 3rd grade teacher turned asset for Reichenbach, the basement setting, creepy flickering light, and his intense presence reminded me of when he took Sebastian Moran to that empty building in “M” (way back in season one). Sherlock can be a scary individual, and back then he was a man capable of torture and murder. The entrance here was a reminder of that, but his dealings with Annie were not scary. He wasn’t necessarily playing the good cop, but he was, on the whole, non-threatening. He even proved her meal wasn’t poisoned! What a gentleman.

Watson, on the other hand, yelled at her!  She was basically the bad cop between the two of them, and I never thought I’d see that day. They really have influenced each other.

And that influence has led to more time spent apart while investigating cases. This isn’t a bad thing, necessarily, asides from us seeing less of them. It speaks to the partnership and their abilities that they can split up and be entirely effective. It makes them a better team while also touting their independence of each other. I will not be surprised if the partners go their separate ways in the finale. I can see Morland’s funeral taking place in London and Sherlock deciding to stay without Watson. Tears may be shed, but it would fit.

But for now, Sherlock and Watson have to destroy Reichenbach. I maintain my stance that I wish we would have gotten to spend more time getting to know Reichenbach, but he’s done enough horrible stuff at this point that my dislike of him has reached the necessary levels to make watching him get snuffed out by Sherlock and Watson emotionally satisfying.

Go get him!

Other Deductions:

  • Morland was a constant presence throughout the series, even if he wasn’t onscreen very often. John Noble played him with serious presence and gravitas, and his death feels heavier as a result.
  • That said, having Reichenbach kill Morland is an easy way to set up Reichenbach’s “big bad” status without having to dive into his personality or show us his influence. We are told what his influence is, and it does sound terrifying (he’s the personification of Samaritan from Person of Interest), but I do wish we had more time to see this influence and not just hear about it!
  • And with THAT said, it’s more important to focus on Sherlock and Watson than Reichenbach or any big bad, so yes, let’s see how they react to the fact that the man who brought them together is gone. I like this.
  • Ooh I just realized that Morland’s death also means his security probably won’t be in place for any of Sherlock’s friends.
  • I think it’s interesting that Sherlock is advocating against a computer predicting human behavior. Sherlock came to this knowledge first hand. He strives to be logical and yet his emotions have often gotten the better of him, so he knows logic/computers can’t predict human behavior with absolute certainty.
  • “What will happen to my son?” Morland, please tell me you knew in your heart that your son is going to take Reichenbach down. If not, it is so sad that Morland died believing Sherlock would also be killed. They didn’t exchange Christmas cards, but Morland loved Sherlock.
  • I’m choosing to believe Morland died knowing Sherlock is going to take Reichenbach down.

Continue Reading

Trending