Connect with us

Pretty Little Liars

Pretty Little Liars: Now You See Me, Now You Don’t (4×12)



I don’t wanna go there… I think I gotta go there… Yes, I am quoting Chris Brown right now and you know what, it’s cause I can. Because all my hopes and dreams and ideas and values have just been shattered by a lanky teacher in a baseball cap… Boy did he look good in that baseball cap. Breathe. Just breathe. I’ll be back once I catch my composure.


Wow. When Marlene King declares World War A, she goes all out. I was waiting in anticipation to see what could possibly be more shocking than Toby being A and yeah, Ezra being A tops the list. Ezra! Mr.fricking Fitz. Can you even believe it? I mean how deceived are you? How betrayed. So betrayed the real Ian Harding had to delete his Twitter account, that’s how. I mean, just where do I begin?!?! Hats off Marlene. Hats off to you lady! Millions of girls all over the world will never EVER believe in love again, yet alone trust a man!!!


“I get it, it’s like you want to know the ending but you want to be surprised.” Wise words Ezra. You predicted the outcome of the night. God, how many hints can Marlene King drop before we finally catch on to what she has up her magical sleeve.  But, aside from this betrAyal, we also got a lot of insight into the whole mystery that is Alison DiLaurentis. All signs point to a ‘this b**ch is alive’. Well ain’t that just another shocker all in itself?! I guess I’ll start at the beginning…wherever that is.


MonA: A decided its about time to play some magic tricks with the girls, cause ain’t nothing scarier than magic. Poof and you might just miss something. The girls are promised, in A style, that if Hanna’s mom goes free, A will unleash hell on earth. Ashley Marin walks out of this finale as a free woman, all charges dropped and A does just as promised. “Hanna won so Mona loses. Find her before the cops or they’ll think you killed her.” A scavenger for Mona, who may or may not be behind all of this.   When Toby finally does find Mona’s whereabouts, she’s safely hidden away in River Valley’s Bed and Breakfast.  He’s led to her through Shauna who presents her with papers. Mona bluntly states, “Is she okay with this” to which Shauna replies, “She doesn’t have a choice.” Who’s okay with what? Who doesn’t have a choice? Jenna, whose probably still in a hospital because of her near death experience? Melissa? After all Shauna did have her mail, addressed to Melissa and Wren. I would really like to say Mona is on the liars’ team, but at this point it’s not looking too good.


Ravenswood: After a magic trick package in the mail, the girls are off to Ravenswood where there is a magic show in full swing. Now you see me, now you don’t. As the girls watch as Aria participates in a disappearing act, Emily gets snatched (kind of hard to imagine this happening in a park full of people ) and pulls a disappearing act of her own. This is the part where I was a little skeptical because Aria calls Emily, who immediately picks up and starts freaking out that she’s in a coffin or a box and hears saws. Instantly, the girls locate her at a saw mill just around the corner. Yeah, right. Either that’s really poor planning, Emily is in on this whole thing, or they have some top of the line GPS systems. Either way, before Emily is turned into vampire dust, red coat does her a favor and shuts down the belt.


Two Red Coats: Wait! Blink. Theres two red coat’s? As Hanna stays behind to free Em, Aria runs after RC1  while Spencer runs after RC2. As Aria fights to the death with red coat, the Ali mask falls off revealing CeCe, who falls over the railing, dangling and screaming for help. Aria, the good soul that she is, tries to pull her up but ultimately fails, as CeCe falls to her death… or so the girls think. Like a cat with nine lives CeCe is gone with the blink of an eye.  Spencer than reveals her findings, which are just a tad bit more exciting… not that Aria doing kung-fu wasn’t totally the greatest thing to ever grace my T.V screen (oh thanks for the lessons by the way Jake, they really came in handy!).


The lAir: Spencer leads the girls to another A lair. But this time I think its the legit lair. The first time we saw A’s lair it was when Mona was working for A. But like many times, she has mentioned that she never knew who she was working for and was just taking orders. This lair revealed quite a lot of information that all of us could use to piece together some loose ends in our mystery. A is everywhere and anywhere because he has survelliance cameras everywhere. Like I mean he’s watching the police, he’s watching the streets, I’m sure he’s even watching the girls houses. For one, A isn’t just following the girls, he’s also following Ali and recording ever one of her moves. The messed up part? A also thinks she’s alive. He doesn’t just have pictures of Ali before her death, but he’s got all the pictures of Ali as red coat. So that’s who Ali is running from? Theres timelines, graphs (I’m sure), creeper photos of everyone making out with everyone, paperwork from A’s own corporation, and of course, the indication that A is a man from the suits and dress shoes in the closet. A be on that suit and tie sh*t (haha I had to).


ezrA: Here’s where all the WTF moments come into play as to Ezra being A. The girls say that Wren cannot be A because he is pictured on the board as someone whose being followed. But theres a pictures of Ezra on the board too?! I don’t think there’s a legit ‘I’m following’ you timeline of Ezra’s life, but he’s got his own creepy photo’s of himself making out with Aria. Who would take those if he’s working alone? AHA! So he isn’t. There has to be someone else working with him, well unless Mona took those. Hm..


Also, if A knows everything how come he didn’t know that Malcolm was his son? Why was that even important? Sure, Ezra could be board shorts, but this is like really something to think about. Could Ezra really pull it all off? And why? Does it mean that when he met Aria in the coffee shop or whatever in season one, it wasn’t by mistake? Did he purposely lure her into a relationship for all of these weird reasons? Did he fake being surprised when she walked into his class on the first day of school and saw her? Had he been planning it for awhile? Did he know about her father affair when she was WAY too young and really illegal? God is he even a teacher? What connection does he have to Ali? After the initial shock, when it comes down to the nitty gritty, there’s just no way Ezra could have been A. Plus, his reaction after walking into the room wasn’t a mad-someones-rumaging-through-my-stuff reaction, it was more of a, ‘what the hell is this why am I here, who led me to this place? Slam door, Aria what!’. Maybe he was led to the “lair” by the real A for some unknown reason and is shocked to find A still tormenting his leading lady?


The saddest part of this whole Ezra is A ordeal is that I was actually so happy to see that when Jake and Aria’s night flopped, she accidentally ran into Ezra who was more than willing to talk English literature with her all night. And when they shared a kiss, I was glowing, thinking how I was going to write about this AHA moment in my review. The moment that I knew would be so crucial because Aria finally realized she was never really over Ezra. All she wanted was to move on. She wanted easy and that’s what she got with Jake. She got a goof her age that didn’t share any of her interests. In reality, all she needed was a man. A man like Fitz. Well yep. That was a crucial moment. Just not in the sense I thought it would be. Now, when Aria realizes she loves Ezra, he’s going to be A and we will all know except her!!!


Grimwauld’s Confession: All we know for sure (remember Ezra never uttered the words, I’m A) is that A is a guy. A guy who Alison was really, and I mean really, afraid of. The girls ran into Grimwauld who finally admitted that she knew Alison and Ali was calling her for help in the sorority house. Why? Cause she has the gift of insight of course. She could look into her crystal ball and tell her who she should be afraid of. Or…. is she all a part of the act? When Ali went missing, Grimwauld went to Rosewood and found Ali buried alive in her backyard. The death reports got that part right, but she wasn’t dead. Her hand was sticking out of the ground (cue that creepy scene from the Halloween episode, its all explained) and Grimwauld pulled her out. She took Ali into her car and drove her to the hospital to go and get some help, when she came out Ali was gone. Well, there is a lot of what if’s in this certain story. From the way it was shown, Ali didn’t look to happy to be with Grimwauld after almost dying in the first place. She seemed scared of her. Could Grimwauld possibly be boardshorts’ mother? Either way, she indicated that Ali is alive. Ali-ve. Get it? She doesn’t want to be found. Why? Because the only reason A is tormenting the girls and making their lives living hell is because he wants to get to Alison. The closer they get to Ali, the more danger she is in. That’s why he follows them, because he want’s to get to her. Which brings me back to why would Ezra want anything from Ali?


Wren/Melissa: This still doesn’t explain why Ali faked her own death. Who was in the casket at the funeral and who the heck did those doctors examined to be Alison. It doesn’t explain Ezra being A. Or Wren being creepy. Or Shauna carrying papers that were addressed to Wren and Melissa. What’s that all about? Are those two back together? Is Wren only here because he’s trying to keep and eye out on Spencer and the girls while Melissa is away? The papers were addressed to Wren with c/o Melissa to London. Have they been getting cozy again? Maybe the person he called last episode wasn’t CeCe, maybe it was Melissa. Gosh. So confusing. More answers= more questions.


CeCe: My question is, if Ali is still alive and CeCe is working with her to get A off the Ali trail, why was CeCe snooping around in a black hoodie (as if she was A) and listening in on Ezra and Aria’s conversation? If she’s redcoat, why is she wearing A’s outfits. And if she is afraid of A, why is she spying on him? Its so contradictory. I think CeCe is working to help Ali and whoever A is, if it is Ezra or not, is trying to get CeCe out of the picture by framing her for the murder and getting her as the next wanted victim for the Rosewood P.D. Truthfully, the idea of two teams is now more clear than ever. Redcoats team is supposably good. The A team in black hoodies is bad. Who the heck is on which team? I have no idea anymore.


Toby/Caleb: Also, another loose end that wasn’t tied up but briefly touched upon was the whole ordeal with Toby’s mother. Was she murdered in Radley? Did she commit suicide? Why does A want to manipulate Toby’s ways of getting this information? Could Toby’s mother be Grimwauld? She does have the pretty eyes. Far stretch but at this point you never know! But with the boys being the most suspicious of all characters, I can’t help but thinking there are way to many positive qualities about Caleb for him to be all good. He got on a bus to Ravenswood and it was the last time we would ever see him in Rosewood. Why? Well, that won’t really be revealed until the Halloween episode. But, there was a point when Grimwauld stated, he’s here, when she refereed to A being in Rosewood looking for Ali. The camera than shot to Caleb hopping on the bus and for some reason I could see him being A or affiliated with A in some way. What do you think? Why else would Caleb stay in Ravenswood?


What do you think about this summer finale? Is Ezra A? Is Mona good or bad? Wren and Melissa together? Is Ali alive? Whose side is CeCe on? Is Grimwauld lying?? Let us know here. Just like the girls, who heed their departure and pick out some costumes, I will be dressing up for the fantastic and horror infused Halloween episode, October 22. Kisses!



Yes It Do- Chris Arena (plays when Toby is looking through mail)

This Isn’t Control- Ms Mr (Aria and Ezra reconnect in the cafe)

1 Comment

1 Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Lizzy Buczak is the founder of CraveYouTV. What started off as a silly blog in her sophomore year at Columbia College Chicago turned her passion for watching TV into an opportunity! She has been in charge of CraveYou since 2011, writing reviews and news content for a wide variety of shows. Lizzy is a Music Business and Journalism major who has written for RADIO.COM, TV Fanatic, Time Out Chicago, Innerview, Pop’stache and Family Time.

    Pretty Little Liars

    8 Murder Mystery TV Shows to Watch and Solve



    8 Murder Mystery TV Shows to Watch and Solve

    Do you fancy yourself a little crime sleuth? Well, throw on your trench coat, grab your magnifying glass, and set out to solve the biggest murder mysteries to hit networks and streaming services!

    The murder mystery genre, while always popular, has been skyrocketing in recent years, with plenty of new TV shows and movies to capture the thrills and chills. 

    There’s nothing like a whodunnit to get you through the day and keep you on your toes. But while some classics date as far back as the 1985 Clue movie or all the Agatha Christie novels now getting new life as films (Murder on the Orient Express or A Haunting in Venice, for example), others, like Knives Out and Glass Onion have revitalized the genre and gave us some of the most captivating shows. 

    There’s no shortage of content for mystery enthusiasts to enjoy—but here’s 8 of our favorites! 


    High Seas – Netflix (3 seasons)

    Netflix allows audiences to dive into the world of suspense on the high seas with its Spanish mystery series set on a luxury cruise ship in the 1940s. A web of love, deceit, and, of course, a string of murders will keep you on your toes as two sisters investigate all passengers onboard and try to piece the clues—and plot twists—together. 


    Nancy Drew – The CW (4 seasons) 

    Who killed Lucy Sable? That’s the question on everyone’s lips as Nancy Drew kicks off its first season with Kennedy McMann taking on the iconic role of the teenage detective. As the seasons continue, she and her Drew Crew become the lifeline to solving crimes in the mystical small town of Horseshoe Bay (much to the dismay of local officials). The intrigue is elevated with supernatural elements and plot points that bring the beloved character into the 21st century.


    Only Murders in the Building – Hulu (3 seasons… so far)

    What happens when you mix murder with comedy? Thankfully, the series has tapped the right people to find out with Selena Gomez, Martin Short, and Steve Martin making up the brilliant (though not always the brightest) trio of true crime podcast enthusiasts-turned-amateur-sleuths who set out on a suspenseful journey to find the killer. The quirky series has become such a global phenomenon that it’s even been able to nail some rather impressive guest stars, like Paul Rudd and Meryl Streep. 


    Death and Other Details – Hulu (Premieres Jan. 16, 2024)

    The newest addition into the fold is Hulu’s mystery drama that takes place on a lavish Mediterranean ocean liner amongst the glamor of the “global elite” (we’re getting some Knives Out and Death of the Nile vibes, but we’re not complaining) and finds Imogene Scott (played by God Friended Me’s Violent Beane) at the wrong place and the wrong time, becoming the prime suspect in a murder mystery. To prove her innocence, she has to partner with the world’s greatest detective, Rufus Cotesworth (Mandy Patinkin), whom she, by no coincidence at all, despises. 


    The Traitors – Peacock (1 Season – Second Premiering Jan 12, 2024)

    Murder mystery games are a party hit, so naturally, they’re a fit for reality TV. The competition, hosted by Alan Cumming, features 20 contestants, a mix of famous people and everyday Americans, as they work through missions in an ancient castle in Scotland. Amid those “Faithfuls” are “Traitors,” who try to eliminate the good guys for the top prize.


    Pretty Little Liars – Freeform (7 Seasons)

    If you by some chance missed the pop culture phenomenon that was teen drama Pretty Little Liars (where have you been?)and you consider yourself a very patient person–then it’s time to give it a whirl. The series follows four best friends whose deepest darkest secrets not only come to light but are used against them by someone calling themselves “A” when investigating the death of their good friend, Alison. 


    The Outsider – HBO (1 Season)

    Based on the chilling best-selling novel by Stephen King, the HBO series finds a detective investigating the gruesome murder of a young boy, with all clues pointing to a family man played by Jason Bateman, all before the case takes a supernatural twist, adding horror and paranormal to your typical murder mystery. 


    Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries – ABC (3 Seasons)

    The Australian drama series infuses the murder mystery genre with glamour and 1920s charm. With a flair for solving crimes and an impeccable sense of fashion, detective Phryne Fisher and her pearl-handled pistol take on murder cases that baffle the police, all while making sure Murdoch Foyle, who she thinks is behind her sister’s disappearance, stays behind bars. 


    Whether you prefer classics, those with a modern twist, or a dose of comedy with your crime, these shows are sure to keep you guessing until the very end! 

    2024 Midseason TV Schedule—All the Network Premiere Dates You Need to Know About

    Continue Reading

    Coffee Table News

    WATCH: The New ‘Pretty Little Liars’ Is Dark AF



    WATCH: The New 'Pretty Little Liars' Is Dark AF

    ‘A’ is not messing around in the Pretty Little Liars spinoff Original Sin.

    If you thought we’d seen the last of ‘A’… think again. The masked stalker is back to torment a new group of little liars on the HBO Max series. 

    The ten-episode season will debut Thursday, July 28 with three episodes. Two new episodes will follow on August 4 and 11, with the final three episodes debuting on August 18.

    A new teaser for the series reveals the tone is going to be much darker than the original ever was, and that’s likely thanks to Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa (Riverdale, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) who serves as writer and co-executive producer. 

    Check out the teaser — complete with a new version of the intro song “Secret.”

    Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin synopsis: Twenty years ago, a series of tragic events almost ripped the blue-collar town of Millwood apart. Now, in present day, a disparate group of teen girls — a brand-new set of Little Liars — find themselves tormented by an unknown Assailant and made to pay for the secret sin committed by their parents two decades ago…as well as their own. In the dark, coming-of-age, horror-tinged drama PRETTY LITTLE LIARS: ORIGINAL SIN, we find ourselves miles away from Rosewood, but within the existing Pretty Little Liars universe — in a brand-new town, with a new generation of Little Liars.

    Continue Reading


    We Don’t Need a ‘Pretty Little Liars’ Reboot



    Pretty Little Liars Farewell, My Lovely

    Pretty Little Liars, which premiered in 2010 on ABC Family (now Freeform), took fans on a rollercoaster ride. The twists and turns were so dramatic and exaggerated, halfway through the show’s 7 season run, many fans began to taper off. 

    Dedicated fans, however, stuck it out despite the fact that the show was rapidly going off the rails. Why? Because they desperately needed to know the identity of “A,” and later, “AD,” once and for all. 

    And the glorious day came on June 27, 2017. As we sat huddled up in front of our TV screens, we were filled with a mix of emotions ranging from confused, misled, and finally, relieved.

    “Relief” is a strange emotion to feel when a show ends. Most fans tend to feel a sadness wash over them when the curtain falls, but with PLLthe finale was a sign that the madness was officially over. 

    The journey with the liars is one we’ll never forget, but let’s face it – most fans are not clamoring for more, especially not a mere three years after the finale. Heck, some of us are still trying to piece that ending together in a way that makes any rational sense. 

    We’re living in a time where reboots are hailed by TV executives as a sound and sure-fire idea. There’s plenty of examples of success: Dynasty, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Charmed, and Roswell, New Mexico. Even revivals that have honed a place in society with shows like The Conners and Fuller House both leading the pack. 

    Pretty Little Liars PlAytime

    PRETTY LITTLE LIARS – “PlAytime” – After Noel Kahn’s abrupt death, the Liars try putting their lives back together again in “Playtime,” the first of the final ten episodes of Freeform’s hit original series “Pretty Little Liars,” airing TUESDAY, APRIL 18 (8:00 – 9:02 p.m. EDT). Fans can catch up on where the Liars left off with an all-day marathon of season seven starting at 11:00 a.m. EDT and running up to the one-hour spring premiere at 8:00 p.m. EDT. (Freeform/Eric McCandless)

    But the one thing that these reboots have in common is that the original shows aired a decade or more ago. The key to a successful reboot is nostalgia; they aim to hook the original fans while also appealing to a brand new generation. 

    Reboots may either reimagine a familiar story with a modern spin and new characters or reunite fans with characters years later a la catching up with friends years after college. 

    It’s obvious that PLL does not fall into the category of a show that warrants a reboot. Not yet, at least. There’s no sound argument when one could argue that enough time has passed to try to take a stab at this overly complex teen mystery drama once again.

    One of my biggest gripes with the PLL reboot, which was officially announced as an HBO Max original, is that it doesn’t center around the original liars. 

    I’m firm in my belief that had it not been for the popularity, relatability, and dynamic of Lucy Hale, Ashley Benson, Troian Belissario, Sasha Pieterse and Shay Mitchell, the show wouldn’t have found a cult-like following or lasted as long as it did. The ladies made the show worth watching and managed to sell us on every single outrageous storyline. 

    Many of us stuck with the series because of our love for the liars. But the reboot, billed as “set miles away from Rosewood” in a new town, with a new set of characters, strips the very identity of PLL. 

    How can you have a show without any involvement from Aria, Emily, Hannah, Spencer, and Alison? They are the pretty little liars. There is no show without them. No one is interested in watching a new generations of teens get tormented by threatening cyber-stalker who knows too much about their life, which was fun to watch partially because it paralleled the rise of technology and the fears surrounding privacy that came along with the emergence of social media.

    Even if the ladies considered (and I use that term loosely — they are over here working on their careers and expanding their families, after all) returning for a reboot, not enough time has passed for a proper reunion. 

    There’s been talk of a potential movie sequel involving the original liars, and truthfully, that’s an idea fans of the original could get behind. It would be a one-time thing, it wouldn’t overstay its welcome or feel forced, and it would hopefully gives fans the follow-up they’ve been dying for. 

    Earlier this year, Hale said she wouldn’t “rule anything out” but ultimately, they’d “need a little more time to pass.”

    “I feel like we would get more out of it if we were, like, 10 years down the road,” she explained to Entertainment Tonight, adding that she’s protective of the show. Hale worked with Roberto Roberto Aguierre-Sacasa on the short-lived Katy Keene, so I’m truly curious to see what she thinks about this upcoming reboot. Note: none of those involved with the original have weighed in or commented yet.  

    Honestly, much of the pushback that I’ve seen about this rumored reboot is for that very reason — fans, even the ones who thought the finale came out of left-field and was a total dumpster fire — are also super protective of it. We don’t want anything or anyone to taint the show’s legacy. 

    We also cannot ignore there’s the fact that PLL’s Marlene King attempted her own reboot of sorts shortly after the series concluded and even centered the storyline around two familiar faces, Alison DiLaurentis (Pieterse) and Mona Vaderwaal (Janel Parish), to drum up support and interest from the core fandom. That didn’t work.

    PLL: Perfectionists lasted a whole ten episodes before Freeform pulled the plug leaving any fans that submitted themselves to yet another A-like mystery in the dark. It’s a shame the series wasn’t give a real chance because it had potential if it stayed true to the books and veered away from trying to make it so much like it’s predecessor. In this case, a complete overhaul could’ve worked if done right. 

    And it’s probably better if I don’t mention Ravesnwood, the second PLL spinoff that centered around Caleb Rivers (Tyler Blackburn), which saw a lot of people seeing dead people in the neighboring town. It’s not that I didn’t enjoy the show’s ten-episode run, but it’s yet another example of the franchise trying to reinvent the wheel and failing miserably. 

    If King couldn’t make these shows work while PLL was at its height, maybe it’s because the audience needed to take a break from the world of A?

    Which brings me to my next point… Roberto Aguierre-Sacasa. You may not know the name, but if you love teen dramas, you’re familiar with his work. He’s the brains behind The CW’s successful and oftentimes disturbing teen thriller Riverdale.

    One fan on Reddit noted that “PLL walked so Riverdale could run,” and let’s be honest, plenty of fans (and critics) have called the show a hot mess. However, that’s what we’ve come to love about Riverdale; it’s wacky, weird, and only tolerable when you suspend all disbelief.

    He’s also proven himself in the reboot-realm with Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. CAOS is an entirely different ballgame; it’s a dark twist on the 90s sitcom Sabrina the Teenage Witch that pulls much of its inspiration from the Archie comics. It offers up an entirely new world featuring new takes on some beloved characters. Not to mention Sabrina wrapped its run in 1996 meaning enough time has passed; the world was ready for the Spellman’s once again. 

    As I mentioned, CAOS is ending with its upcoming season while Aguierre-Sacasa’s other series, Katy Keene, was cancelled after just a season at The CW. 

    I’m not questioning Aguierre-Sacasa’s qualifications — I’m a fan of his shows — but I don’t think jumping into and revamping a still-fresh franchise is necessary right now.

    Apparently, neither does Twitter. One person commented that he should “stick to one show and make that good.” I’d prefer HBO Max gave Katy Keene another try rather than investing into this PLL reboot. 

    The reboot seems to be hoping to capitalize on the the original fandom (the brief teaser features the same imagery as the original right down to the logo), but the fandom has opposed a reboot from the start. And they’ll be further alienated with the reboot’s description of a “horror-tinged, coming-of-rage” version.

    Aguierre-Sacasa’s strength lies within creating shows permeated with twisted mysteries that have a campy, horror vibe, which is tonally different than the psychological mind games we’ve come to expect from PLL

    There’s room for another teen thriller, obviously, but maybe it would be best to leave the franchise alone and call the show, which is shaping up to be its own entity anyway, something else entirely? “Original Sin” minus the “Pretty Little Liars” would have given the series a fresh-slate without any comparisons.

    Here’s the show’s description so you can decide for yourself: “Twenty years ago, a series of tragic events almost ripped the blue-collar town of Millwood apart. Now, in the present day, a group of disparate teen girls — a brand-new set of Little Liars — find themselves tormented by an unknown Assailant and made to pay for the secret sin their parents committed two decades ago. as well as their own.”

    I’ll watch merely out of curiosity and because I’ve made television my job, but man, I haven’t even had time to miss PLL yet. 

    If you really need to feel the PLL-void in your life, the best thing to do is just stream the original episodes, because I think we can all agree that some things are better off left alone… at least until enough time has passed to revisit them through a new lens.

    Continue Reading