Connect with us
This Is Us Review The Hill Season 6 Episode 9 This Is Us Review The Hill Season 6 Episode 9

This Is Us

This Is Us Review – The Hill (6×09)

THIS IS US -- "The Hill" Episode 609 -- Pictured: (l-r) Chris Sullivan as Toby, Chrissy Metz as Kate -- (Photo by: Ron Batzdorff/NBC)



The second part of the Big Three trilogy focused on Kate’s journey to believing in herself. 

But I’d be a liar if I said This Is Us Season 6 Episode 9 wasn’t a conflicting episode that broke my KaTobe heart into a million pieces. 

Even though I knew their break-up was coming, it didn’t lessen the blow of watching their marriage implode. Seeing it pan out on screen — the demise of a relationship that once found two people so deeply entwined together — was shattering, especially because there were moments were they both had valid points. 

And sometimes, that’s honestly the worst part of a divorce or break-up. When two people are both right, there’s no path moving forward.

That was the case with KaToby.

The truth is that they are on their own individual paths to happiness and fulfillment. They’ve created something truly beautiful together, but it’s run its course. They will forever be bonded by their children, Jack and Hailey, but living in two different cities isn’t sustainable, moving to one city isn’t a solution as it unfairly requires one of them to uproot a life that they actually love, and sacrifices will only force them to resent each other in the long run. 

One might argue that the kids would be better off with both parents living together, but the kids will be better off with two happy parents, even if it means that they are divorced.

I found myself really conflicted on who to side with, which means that this episode did what it was intended to do. 

On one hand, you can’t fault Toby for enjoying the fact that he feels valued at his job as he’s always strived for that. 

And you also can’t blame him for wanting a better life for his family. He’s clearly put a lot of thought into this as he has considered Jack’s expenses, and it’s admirable that he wants to work this hard to provide his children with the kid of life that they deserve.

There’s also nothing wrong with Toby feeling himself or for changing. Everyone changes. 

The Toby that Kate is missing — the man she claims to have fallen in love with — wasn’t a happy guy. She fell in love with him because his depression matched hers, but it’s not fair to ask Toby to go back to being the a miserable and self-loathing person. Toby really nailed it when he asked her what was wrong with him  in the present-day and why she hated seeing him happy. 

On the other hand, Toby’s ultimatum to Kate was also unfair. He basically made the decision that if she didn’t move the whole family to San Fran, that the marriage was over. 

Kate had absolutely no say in the matter, and for someone who struggled with self-identity and confidence, and who didn’t see a future for herself, it’s not easy to give up a life where she’s finally happy and enjoying life. 

And Kate is. She loves her kids, she loves her job, she loves being near her family. Kate still has her struggles, but this is the happiest we’ve ever seen her, and she deserves it. 

They both do, which is why there’s only one solution — allow their paths to divulge. 

Kate’s happiness, however, has nothing to do with the fact that Toby is out of the house. 

It’s unfair to say she pushed him out because he mad a choice. The least he could do is own that. 

Since they’ve been living in different cities, it was inevitable for them to start different lives apart from each other. It’s no ones fault, it’s just life. 

In addition to Toby’s ultimatum, Kate walking up that hill seemed to be the final straw in their marriage. 

She didn’t succumb to the pressure he put on her, but instead, for the first time felt empowered to do what she wanted to do. 

At her highest moment, she called Phillip — which is telling in its own right — to throw her name into the ring for a position at the school. 

The moment was deeply profound as it was supported by two scenes from the past in which Jack and, separately, Kevin and Randall both championed Kate to believe in herself. 

It took her 40 years, but she finally did it. 

And in that moment, regardless of the tug-of-war on my emotions following Kate and Toby’s spat — I couldn’t help but let out an audible cheer for our girl.

Unlike Kevin, Kate’s cautious and doesn’t just jump into the deep water. She analyzes, over analyzes, and psyches herself out. But this was her moment; she did it, and she always could. She took Rebecca’s words to heart and made the leap and took the chance. She finally had things figured out, she finally saw a path towards the future she’s always dreamt about.

And it seemed as though she was fine with it coming at the expense of her marriage to a man she barely even recognized anymore. 

I also can’t blame Kate for not wanting to move to San Francisco. Those hills are no joke; I always refuse to drive out there because it’s absolutely terrifying. 

The one thing I’m confident about is that Toby and Kate will end their relationship on good terms. They fell out of love, plain and simple, which is no one’s fault. But there’s still plenty of love there as they care for each other and wants what’s best not only for themselves and for their children. 

Throughout all of this, it was nice to see that while personal happiness is always very important, they were both prioritizing their children’s needs. Toby, as I mentioned previously, wanted to ensure that they would have a quality of life, while Kate wasn’t enthusiastic about the idea of moving because it would take a toll on baby Jack, who just figured out the whole layout of the house and was learning how to get to the park. 

As painful and beautiful as this episode was, it was necessary, and it’ll guarantee that these two people much happier in the future. 

What did you think of the episode? Were you on Team Toby or Team Kate? Or were you torn between them both?

Do you think a divorce is on the horizon? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below! 

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Lizzy Buczak is the founder of CraveYouTV. What started off as a silly blog in her sophomore year at Columbia College Chicago turned her passion for watching TV into an opportunity! She has been in charge of CraveYou since 2011, writing reviews and news content for a wide variety of shows. Lizzy is a Music Business and Journalism major who has written for RADIO.COM, TV Fanatic, Time Out Chicago, Innerview, Pop’stache and Family Time.

This Is Us

This Is Us Review – The Train (6×17)



This Is Us Review The Train Season 6 Episode 17

There are some shows, some characters, and some families that come into your life and change everything. 

Since its premiere, This Is Us has always been that show with those life-changing characters and families. Each episode has been an emotional tsunami that opened the flood gates and assured fans that it was okay — more than okay, actually — to feel all the feels and let out the tears. 

The series sent waves when it introduced three timelines that all connected with each other, so the expectations have been high for the final few episodes, especially the penultimate episode that said goodbye to the matriarch, Rebecca Pearson. 

Everyone always raves about what a great guy Jack Pearson is — and he was a terrific father albeit a flawed man — but no one ever gives Rebecca the credit she deserves. 

Until now. 

The episode, which detailed Rebecca’s journey to the end, highlighted that Rebecca was really the glue that held it all together in the face of loss, heartache, and trauma. She endured so much so that, in their individual ways, her children could thrive. And she made sure that — until her very last breath — her children were taken care of in a way that only a mother can. 

She held on for so long for them, and wow, she really deserved that rest. 

When you think of death, you typically think of pain and suffering, which makes all the sense in the world. It’s hard not to. But This Is Us once again challenged those surface-level emotions by showcasing Rebecca’s death as a beautiful and natural process in this journey we call life. 

The end doesn’t always have to be sad. It can be a celebration of a full life lived. Rebecca’s sure was. 

Dan Fogelman and team brilliantly brought to life the quote: “It is said that your life flashes before your eyes just before you die.”

For Rebecca, that life was weaved in seamlessly through her journey to the caboose car on the train. Ever since she was a little child, Rebecca absolutely loved riding on the train with her father, so it was fitting that she took one last ride with a final destination in mind. 

I mean, the writing was exceptional as it hit on every major and minor moment that meant anything to the series and these characters.  

It was also a creative way to incorporate and celebrate all the people that shaped the show and made an impact on Rebecca’s life along the way. 

William guided Rebecca on the journey with all of the wisdom that he collected throughout the years. Their stories have been connected since the moment he left Randall at the firehouse. He gave Rebecca the third child that completed her family, and so, it was fitting that he was the one to escort her in her final moments. 

Dr. K made an appearance to commend Rebecca on truly living his advice about taking lemons and making lemonade to the fullest — she took everything that was thrown her way and she made the sweetest damn lemonade. She turned her life into this big, messy, gigantic, and spectacular thing.

And when her life flashed before her eyes, the pain was overshadowed by the love and the light. 

Obviously, at the forefront were her three children, the Big Three — Randall, Kevin, and Kate — but there was also the incredible family that they all built. There were grandchildren, great grandchildren (well, in the making), wives, husbands, ex-husbands, baby mommas, everyone together as one unit. The love that Rebecca gave her children was extended to every single new “Pearson.”

The house wasn’t empty in her final days — it was filled with people who loved and cared for Rebecca in many different ways, including people who learned from her over the years and found her to be a role model and source of inspiration. 

As all those loved ones said their final goodbyes, it was acknowledged that Rebecca heard everything they were saying deep in her subconscious as she saw flashes of memorabilia that meant something to her throughout the years along with visions of characters in various moments in time.

When Beth thanked Rebecca for being a guiding force and showing her what it was like to be a mother, Rebecca saw her as both a teenager and a grown woman. 

When Sophie said goodbye and mentioned that her love story with Kevin was a once-in-a-lifetime love much like Rebecca and Jack’s, Rebecca saw Kevin and Sophie when they were toddlers, teens, and adults. 

Rebecca was lucky enough to be part of every single moment — the good and the bad. She was the bedrock of the family and had a fierce love and loyalty for her kids. 

As she made her way through the train, there was also a sweet moment with Miguel, though, admittedly, it felt very brief particularly when you think about how much Rebecca meant to him. The man dedicated his whole life to taking care of her. She was his whole life, and while I know that he wasn’t her one true love, he was such an important person to her, so I wish there was a little bit more love for him. 

However, Mandy Moore also sold that chapter in her character’s life as she displayed the emotions that come along with confusion, excitement, and fear all wrapped up into one.

Rebecca knew that her time was running out, and she was trying to make sense of it all while absorbing all that was being thrown her way. She was proud of what she accomplished yet sad that she was leaving it all behind. 

There were a few side stories, including Deja’s pregnancy, and even one final mystery that magnificently tied it all together. 

Deja informed Randall that he was going to be a “grandpappy,” and the magnitude of life vs. death of it all could be felt. They always say, as one life ends, another begins. 

It was revealed that Deja was pregnant with Malik’s child, which allows their relationship to come full circle. I’m happy for those crazy-in-love kids. 

However, the idea of one life ends, another begins was also underscored with the introduction of Marcus and his family. 

We met Marcus and his family during a traumatic moment in their lives when a car crash landed him in the hospital. 

It wasn’t immediately clear how Marcus’s story fit into the grand scheme of things but isn’t that always the case with This Is Us?

Eventually, we learned that Marcus’s father had a heart-to-heart with Jack Pearson on the night of the house fire — and as we know — moments prior to his death. 

This Is Us Review The Train Season 6 Episode 17

THIS IS US — “The Train” Episode 617 — Pictured: (l-r) Justin Hartley as Kevin, Sterling K. Brown as Randall — (Photo by: Ron Batzdorff/NBC)

And even then, Jack had it in him to pass on some sound piece of advice — a motto about lemons that Marcus’s family lived by for all these years. 

Two families going through absolute hell that were unknowingly connected on a cosmic level. 

They weren’t much different from the Pearsons, except that Marcus survived while Jack died that night. A real “one lives while the other dies” kind of moment. 

Another life quote also comes to mind at this moment: “everything happens for a reason.”

Jack’s death was a pivotal moment for the Pearson clan as it changed everything and shaped them into the people that we know today, but if the scales tipped and Marcus died instead of Jack, then the world would’ve never gotten groundbreaking research about Alzheimer’s disease. 

Marcus, again unknowingly, went on to make great strides in eliminating and treating the disease that killed Rebecca. 

Not everyone’s bad day is a bad day. There is balance and order. As William explained — if you look at the whole picture, you’ll see the beauty even in the sad moments. 

And, of course, if we were to get really technical, Jack would’ve never wanted the doctor to save him over a young boy. 

Rebecca’s subconscious kept telling William that she was “waiting for someone” throughout the episode, and it soon became clear that it wasn’t Jack. She knew, just like we did, that she would see her husband again. She was, however, waiting for Kate, who was on a 12-hour flight back from London after taking her music program for the blind international.

A mother just knows (kind of like Beth knew that Deja was pregnant before she even said anything), call it motherly intuition, so Rebecca held on until all three of her children were by her side. 

As they said their final goodbyes, she acknowledged that she heard everything with one last hand squeeze. 

Now, naturally, you were already balling your eyes out this whole time. And if you know anything about This Is Us, you knew that Rebecca’s reunion with Jack was going to be the final moment. When she finally saw her beloved husband, it would indicate her passing. 

You braced yourself and it still hit so hard. 

When Rebecca laid down and turned to face Jack in bed, I looooost it. 

Then, she simply said “hey,” which is what the children told her to say when she finally saw him, and I was in shambles. 

It was so pure, simple, and perfect because it’s what we all envision our final moments being. We’re all staring down that barrel hoping that our end will be as comforting as Rebecca’s.

We want to see the people that have passed on and we want them to guide us since they’ve already crossed over. And we want to reunite with our one true love. 

Rebecca gets to rest easy knowing that she did everything she could for her kids and left them as capable adults with their own families to raise. 

It was a beautiful end to a beautiful story. 

And we’re not done. We have one final episode to say goodbye to the Pearson clan, so get your tissues ready!

Other Thoughts

  • How nice is it to see all the kids now? Like Kevin’s children as preteens! 
  • Why did Kevin look older than everyone else? Sophie barely aged. Nicky still looked the same! 
  • Toby continues to be the show’s comedic relief by asking Rebecca, on her deathbed, if she liked him better than Phillip. 
  • There were so many good moments, but Joni Mitchell? Flawless touch. It was the soundtrack to Rebecca’s life because it led her to Jack. 

What did you think of the episode?

Continue Reading

This Is Us

This Is Us Review – Family Meeting (6×16)



This Is Us Review Family Meeting Season 6 Episode 16

I don’t know how I thought that I was going to hold it together watching the final episodes of This Is Us, but the storytelling does not allow for there to be a single dry eye in the room. 

This Is Us Season 6 Episode 16 leaned heavily into the emotional aspect of a mother’s love. 

A mother’s love knows no bounds, especially when that mother is Rebecca Pearson. 

Rebecca poured her heart and soul into raising the Big Three. She was a devoted mother who sacrificed everything, even when she didn’t exactly know what she was doing or how to do it.

As Randall put it, she was magic, so watching that magic fade away was uncomfortable and difficult. 

It forced the Big Three to look at their mother in a different way; she was no longer the caregiver, she was now in need of their care. 

The series has always been really great at showing parallels between then and now, but the plot device was especially useful in “Family Meeting” to underscore that the roles between a mother and her children were reversed. 

In the same way that she fed them, clothed them, bathed them, and put them to sleep, they were now pitching it to feed her, clothe her, bathe her, and put her to sleep. 

And it hit audiences in the feels not only because we’ve all come to love the Pearson clan and feel like we’re extended family members, but also because it’s a reality for each and every one of us because it’s life. And Dan Fogelman, the cast, and the crew have effortlessly, beautifully, and heartbreakingly captured it all through the lens of a single family.

As Randall, Kevin, and Kate debated what they should do with their mother now that Miguel was gone and her disease was worsening, it forced them to dig deep into themselves and into their childhood. 

They couldn’t see eye-to-eye, which Rebecca anticipated when she appointed Kate as her guardian. And it’s a good thing she did. 

Kevin and Randall both meant well, but they both had tunnel vision. They weren’t actually seeing the situation, and therefore, they weren’t seeing Rebecca — the person she is now. 

Kate was silent throughout much of the meeting. She took a step back to reflect. She connected with her mother. She reminded them to actually look at their mother, see her in this fragile state, and be with her. 

Admittedly, the scene of Randall and Kevin brushing their mother’s hair and lotioning her hands gutted me. There is such a pure love between all of them that just makes up for all the bad moments. 

This Is Us Review Family Meeting Season 6 Episode 16

THIS IS US — “Family Meeting” Episode 616 — Pictured: (l-r) Chrissy Metz as Kate, Justin Hartley as Kevin, Mandy Moore as Rebecca, Sterling K. Brown as Randall — (Photo by: Ron Batzdorff/NBC)

It was also such a raw moment that brought things full circle and reminded just how fleeting time is. 

Eventually, Kevin presented the only logical solution to their dilemma that allowed Rebecca’s wishes to be fulfilled. She would live out her days in the cabin surrounded by family and none of her children would be forced to make their lives “smaller” because of it. 

Kevin may have been a troublemaker for much of his life, and it took him a while to figure things out, but he was definitely on the right path by wanting to give Rebecca those “lazy Sundays.”

What made Rebecca such a great mother is that she loved her family — every single member of it. 

What was supposed to be “one baby” ended up being three, and eventually, a whole clan of Pearson’s waiting to lend a hand to take care of the matriarch. It was, as the title noted, an actual “family meeting.” 

When Kevin presented his plan for Rebecca, it was a definite moment where he was proving that he had finally grown up. 

He wasn’t doing it alone either because Sophie, a nurse, was on-board, along with Madison, Elijah, and the twins, who would move to the East Coast to be closer to their families. And Nicky and Edie lived at the cabin as well, which meant that Rebecca would be surrounded by the family she created with Jack. A family that stemmed from one moment at the bathroom in Froggy’s. 

Rebecca was always at the center of the family, so it was fitting that taking care of her seemed to be what brought everyone together for years to come. 

Mandy Moore has done an outstanding job as Rebecca in every phase of her life; someone needs to give that woman an Emmy for her work. 

The supporting cast, however, are the Big Three’s better halves. It’s not just a saying, it’s fact. 

Beth has been part of the family for so long that she knows exactly when to make a break for it. She knows that she doesn’t meddle with Big Three business. She knows her husband so well, she knows exactly what he’s thinking and what he’s saying. 

Sophie has been around for nearly as long — with some gaps in between — so she was perfect at channeling her inner-Kevin in the situation. 

And while Phillip made a good point that they were making jokes while the Big Three dealt with the weight of making a decision about their mother’s soul-crushing disease, he also hasn’t experienced the ups-and-downs that come with being a Pearson so he doesn’t quite get that lightening the mood is absolutely necessary. 

Sophie and Beth were the comedic relief in what would have otherwise been a very dark and depressing episode. They symbolize the people in your life who cope with bad situations by cracking jokes.

Toby was also a light in the darkness when he cracked a joke about getting back together after reminding Kate to stay confident while dealing with her brothers and their big personalities. 

I love that Kate turned to both Toby and Phillip to get advice about her decision. She may have been a “late bloomer,” but she’s truly bloomed into her own and has some really great people in her life. 

As the train heads towards the final two episodes of This Is Us, there’s no delaying the inevitable — Rebecca’s death.  

I always thought that Jack’s death was going to be the one that hit the hardest, and while Miguel’s was a close second, it’s Rebecca’s passing that is going to have us all picking up the pieces for a very long time.

What did you think of the episode?

Did you like that The Big Three showed a level of maturity when making this big decision about their mother’s future? Were you glad to see the rest of the family equally involved in the decision-making process?

And how are you preparing for the final episodes?

Continue Reading

This Is Us

This Is Us Review – Miguel Story… Finally! (6×15)



This Is Us Review Miguel Season 6 Episode 15

Miguel finally got his time to shine! 

To be quite honest, Miguel deserved so much more than a single episode to honor his life, but at the very least, he got that. 

On This Is Us Season 6 Episode 15, Miguel was acknowledged, seen, and loved. 

We saw him as a child when his family uprooted his life to the U.S. We saw him navigate the complexities of being an immigrant by applying to jobs using both his real name and an English name. We saw him try to make something of himself and embrace where his path led. 

We saw him fall in love with Shelly and have a beautiful life. And we saw that life take a dark turn as one late night led to another and eventually, to the demise of his family. 

We saw him grapple with Jack’s death, get closer to Rebecca, and then move to Houston to start over. We saw him isolated and lonely as he struggled to maintain a relationship with his kids, who hated him and sided with their other, and his own father, who sadly passed away before they could ever find closure.

We saw him reconnect with Rebecca and genuinely smile for the first time in a while. We saw their first date after eight years apart — Rebecca made the first move.

We saw them broach the topic of Jack and what he would think about their romance, and like much of the audience, the consensus among them was that Jack would want what’s best for them. He’d want them to be happy.

We saw Miguel and Rebecca definitely not “ease into” breaking the news about their relationship to the kids.

We also saw Miguel take care of Rebecca, often putting her needs ahead of his own and neglecting his own health.

His mother, who dedicated her life to taking care of her disabled sister Gabi, once told him that love is unconditional and he seemed to have taken it to heart. 

He wanted to be there for Rebecca every step of the way. And he was too proud to call it quits when the going got tough because he made a promise to her. 

I love that the Big Three stepped in when they realized that Miguel could no longer shoulder the responsibility of being Rebecca’s caregiver. 

It was sweet that he wanted to be, but after the fall in the snow which really hurt his back, it was clear that they overlooked the glaring fact that Miguel was aging right alongside his vibrant wife. 

Rebecca’s sickness took precedence, but there was no denying that Miguel had a hard life where he wasn’t exactly seen. 

The Big Three finally saw him and understood his needs as well. 

Most of all, they finally acknowledged that they loved him and appreciated that he was part of the family. It was beautiful to see because Miguel has always been such an outsider in the family. He was a trooper about it, but that doesn’t mean it didn’t hurt someday. 

This Is Us Review Miguel Season 6 Episode 15

THIS IS US — “Miguel” Episode 615 — Pictured: Jon Huertas as Miguel — (Photo by: Ron Batzdorff/NBC)

Also, props to Beth for knowing that Migs’ was endgame. She’s good. 

By about the midway point of the episode, it was clear that Miguel’s time was coming to an end much sooner than Rebecca’s. 

And that’s the thing about a disease like Alzheimer’s — it’s a gut punch day in and day out, but it also takes its time sometimes. 

Someone with Alzheimer’s can outlive someone with, let’s say, a heart condition, which it seems Miguel had. 

I have to give props to Kevin for stepping up and reaching out to Miguel’s son in hopes of encouraging him not to squander this final goodbye and leave things unfinished. 

Not being able to say goodbye to Jack has affected Kevin immensely, so it was big of him to recognize that and reach out to the son, even if was to put the ball in his court. 

He was receptive, thankfully, and Miguel got to enjoy a holiday or two with his kids, steps kids, grandkids, and step grandkids by his side.

There’s nothing more you could really ask for. 

Kevin was also the one who opposed Miguel’s relationship with Rebecca the most. As the sensitive kid who was wholly devoted to his father, it makes sense. And though it took him years to warm up to the idea, I’m glad he finally did. He was a a huge source of support in Miguel’s final years, and that had to have meant the world. 

And eventually, Miguel passed away. I’d like to think that he reconnected with Jack Pearson somewhere in heaven and they are both looking over Rebecca. 

The symbolism of the tree that they planted together was deep and beautiful — just like their life together. 

Miguel never wanted to leave Rebecca’s side, and he never would have willingly. The episode also confirms that the reason Miguel isn’t by Rebecca’s deathbed is that he died years prior. 

The episode was an incredible run-through of a man’s life, and in a way, it’s almost as fast and fleeting as life itself. One minute you’re a kid playing ball with your whole life ahead of you, the next minute you’re staring down at a life lived and chock full of memories — both good and bad. They all mold together to shape the person you are today. And Miguel? He was a character who was flawed, but he tried his damn best. And he loved with every single ounce of his being. 

We finally, finally, finally got to know his story, and it was worth the wait. 

Continue Reading