Connect with us
'Tracker' Fans Don't Fully Trust New Character Mel Day 'Tracker' Fans Don't Fully Trust New Character Mel Day

Tracker

‘Tracker’ Fans Don’t Trust This One Character—Are They Onto Something?

Credit: tracker

Published

on

Tracker introduced a brand new character to replace the void left behind at Reenie’s (Fiona Rene) office following the exit of Velma, played by Abby McEnany. Before the start of season 3, Eric Graise, who plays tech whiz Bobby, also left the series, with replacement Randy (Legacies‘ Chris Lee) sticking around for longer than anticipated. 

On Tracker Season 3 Episode 3, Reenie hired Mel Day (Cassady McClincy Zhang) as an assistant, but though she was vetted by Randy prior to the interview, there were some moments that left fans feeling a little concerned about her intentions.

Reenie immediately clicked with Mel, but plenty of fans noticed some red flags during the interaction, especially when she asked about rewardist Colter Shaw (Justin Hartley). There was also the fact that while Mel is qualified for the job, she keeps Reenie on a pedestal, knowing her whole work history, which she wasn’t ashamed to reveal. 

And there’s also the fact that her mother was killed, but the justice system failed her, so the person responsible was never captured. The fact that she’s already expressed interest in Colter’s line of work, while being someone who would benefit from his knowledge, gives off the impression that she has an ulterior motive for seeking out the gig with Reenie. That might not be a bad thing, per se, but it’s also not great that she’s not being fully honest about why she needs the job. 

While Tracker seemingly wanted fans to be just as impressed with Mel Day as Reenie was, it ended up backfiring, with many expressing concern over her character’s backstory and motivations, reading between the lines to pick up on some things that didn’t sit right with them.

“What was the point of getting rid of Velma just to bring on Mel who is shady AF?” someone wrote bluntly on X, and while we can understand the need for fresh faces to shake things up, it almost feels like they never gave Velma a full shot, with her character being sorely underutilized. 
 
Another chimed in, writing, “Why do I got a odd feeling that Mel might be a serial killer or a stalker #TrackerCBS,” which isn’t too far-fetched considering how much she knew about Reenie and Colter.
 
“Not a fan of this episode and Mel is creeping me out too! #TrackerCBS,” someone else noted, as another pointed out, “

Idk, I can’t grasp it… But there’s something about Mel that’s not sitting right with me. #TrackerCBS.”
 
“Mel’s mom was shot and they never found out who did it,” another raised the suspicion. 
 
Maybe it was just the actress’s presence, and we could’ve totally misjudged her based on the minimal screentime she’s had, and she could end up being a great addition to the series, but you can’t blame fans for having their guard up, considering the number of shady people Colter and Reenie have crossed paths with in their line of work. 
 
What do you think? Is there something off about Mel? Will she show her true colors down the line–or are we just judging her too harshly? 
 

1 Comment

1 Comment

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Lizzy Buczak is the founder of CraveYouTV. What started off as a silly blog in her sophomore year at Columbia College Chicago turned her passion for watching TV into an opportunity! She has been in charge of CraveYou since 2011, writing reviews and news content for a wide variety of shows. Lizzy is a Music Business and Journalism major who has written for RADIO.COM, TV Fanatic, Time Out Chicago, Innerview, Pop’stache and Family Time.

    Tracker

    ‘Tracker’ Season 4 Premiere Opens With a Deeply Disturbing Case and Colter in Fighting Shape

    Published

    on

    Tracker Season 4 Episode 1

    Tracker has gone to some dark places before, but human smuggling may be the darkest storyline yet.

    Kicking off Season 4 with Colter single-handedly taking on Russian organized crime is a bold move, immediately raising the stakes and signaling that the series isn’t holding back or messing around. And it’s pushing Colter into even more dangerous territory, forcing us to suspend disbelief a bit. 

    At this rate, he needs a full-blown tactical team at the ready, though, as always, Colter proves he’s more than capable on his own. 

    His near-perfect aim also remains intact… and we’ll let the show have that one so he can remain the hero we all need each week. The world is bleak, so we need a good guy to root for!

    In the Season 4 premiere titled“Safe Harbor,” Colter takes on a case involving a missing father of two, with the man’s son, Charlie, who reaches out after finding his information on Reddit. 

    Charlie claims his brother is missing, but Colter quickly catches on to the truth—fearing DCFS would separate him and his sibling, Charlie lied to get help.

    Colter agrees to take the case anyway, understandably, as he understands the hardships single parents face. 

    He also recognizes the emotional weight Charlie is carrying, as he knows what it’s like to have to step up after losing a parent to be there for your siblings. 

    Colter’s investigation leads him to a connection between Shawn and a woman named Stephanie, who works at the port.

    Shawn recently purchased a gun to protect her, so it’s obvious they’re wrapped up in something dangerous. 

    Things escalate quickly when Randy tracks their last location to a crime scene with a male’s dead body. Thankfully, the victim isn’t Shawn but rather Stephanie’s ex, Brent. 

    Still, this is no romantic dispute gone wrong—it runs much deeper.

    Tracker Season 4 Episode 1

    “Safe Harbor” — Coverage of the CBS Original Series Tracker, scheduled to air on the CBS Television Network. Pictured: Derek Phillips as Sean Wooledge, Justin Hartley as Colter Shaw, Hiram Murray as Security Guard, Photo: Tyler Golden/CBS ©2026 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    Using his charm, Colter secures surveillance footage from a nearby gas station, revealing that both Stephanie and Shawn were taken following the tussle at the house. A partial license plate gives him just enough to track the couple down before it’s too late. 

    Shawn gives Colter a brief breakdown of the situation—Stephanie’s ex worked for dangerous people and had been pressuring her to make a container disappear, something she refused to do.

    It’s an all-hands-on-deck case, as 

    Reenie digs into the ex’s background and discovers he was tied to a federal investigation.

    The people Brent was involved with? The Russians. And what were they trafficking in that container? People, not good. 

    Even in the face of that danger, Colter doesn’t hesitate, risking everything to save Stephanie—and everyone trapped inside the containers. 

    Thankfully, he succeeds, bringing Shawn home safely to his children, who had already lost too much. 

    Some of the most compelling Tracker moments come when Colter takes cases that aren’t about the paycheck, this being one of them.

    He knew Charlie couldn’t afford it, but he saw himself in him, even praising him for showing good judgment and instinct, doing exactly what he would’ve done. 

    Charlie feels like a future Colter 2.0—and without that instinct, the case would have ended very differently, as Colter found Shawn and Stephanie just in time. 

    As far as season premieres go, this was a solid hour, smoothly dropping viewers right back into Colter’s world without missing a beat.

    Colter remains a lone wolf, for now, while relying on his network for intel, though hopefully that won’t be the case all season—especially with hints that he may be getting a more permanent love interest.

    Reenie is also eyeing a new office space, a subtle way of addressing the show’s shift to filming in California instead of British Columbia.

    The premiere also sets up a new (or rather, old) connection for Reenie. Maxine reveals that Adam—someone who remembers her from their school days—is interested now that she’s single.

    Reenie may not be smitten with Adam just yet, but fans of The Vampire Diaries surely are, as Adam is played by Michael Malarkey (TVD’s Enzo), who is described as “disarmingly handsome,” (again, we know), intelligent, and sophisticated—with just enough of a bad-boy edge. He works as a private investigator for high-end law firms.

    Could this finally be the answer to Reenie’s love life? Let’s be honest—her track record hasn’t exactly been great.

    Read next: Is Russell Shaw Returning for ‘Tracker’ Season 4? Jensen Ackles Finally Reveals What’s Next

    Continue Reading

    Tracker

    CBS Reveals First-Look at ‘Tracker’ Season 4—And Colter Shaw Is in Fighting Shape

    Published

    on

    Justin Hartley

    Tracker fans, it’s almost that time again! 

    The fourth season of Tracker is upon us, and Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw is in fighting shape in the first look released on CBS today. 

    Returning on Sunday, October. 4, 2026, the series doesn’t miss a beat, jumping right into the action as Shaw—and his biceps (they did not take a summer hiatus!)—return to find people and save the day.

    “Randy, you got something for me?” Shaw asks his go-to right-hand man, who informs him that there’s a case of a missing single dad “who left home last night and never came back.”

    In another scene, a woman asks Shaw to “please find” her daughter, as he promises, “I’ll do everything I can.” And we know he means business, as he’s seen climbing cliffs, dodging boulders thrown his way, and throwing some mean punches. I’d hate to be the guy on the receiving end. 

    The promo also gives fans a look at the new scenery following the show’s shake-up, relocating from Vancouver to Los Angeles. You may not be able to tell at first glance, but the tone is warmer and sunnier. Is that a tan we’re seeing?

    Hartley previously revealed to The Wrap in May that he didn’t think the background change would be a big deal, as the show’s setting changes weekly as he travels the U.S., taking him wherever his cases are. 

    Not much is known about the direction of Tracker Season 4, for now, but the first episode, titled “Safe Harbor,” embraces the L.A. backdrop right off the bat, as the season premiere takes him to “a dangerous criminal operation at the Port of Los Angeles.”

    As for what fans can expect, we know Chris Lee is coming back as Randy, with Fiona Rene returning as Reenie. 

    And yes, Russell Shaw, played by Supernatural’s Jensen Ackles, has also confirmed his return in a guest-star capacity, which is reassuring considering Russell took a dangerous job to keep his brother safe in the season 3 finale. 

    “What he brings to the show is pretty extraordinary. He’s really talented and extremely ugly. It’s really hard to look at,” Hartley quipped during the Televerse 26, adding, “But other than the looks, he has this incredible work ethic and charm and charisma and talent and all of that. Wonderful, and everybody knows that.”

    Fans have loved seeing Hartley and Ackles bring the Shaw brothers to life on screen, so whenever Russell returns, we’ll hopefully get insight into what it is he found out about what his father was doing to Colter when he was a child. 

    Again, Tracker returns Oct. 4, 2026—watch the promo below:

    Continue Reading

    Tracker

    Is Russell Shaw Returning for ‘Tracker’ Season 4? Jensen Ackles Finally Reveals What’s Next

    Published

    on

    Tracker Season 3 Episode 2 Leverage

    Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw may be the lead on Tracker, but the best character on the series is his brother, Russell Shaw, played by guest star Jensen Ackles.

    With Tracker Season 4 on the horizon, fans are wondering whether Ackles will return this season, and the actor just revealed what he knows about his character’s fate. 

    Turns out, they’ve been keeping the Supernatural alum in the dark. And despite the season already in production, Ackles hasn’t gotten the comeback call… at least, not yet.

    “I dip in and out of the show, Tracker. Just started its fourth season, so, I’m waiting for the phone call,” he reportedly said during Creation Toronto 2026, according to Robyn Phillips’s YouTube.

    Obviously, that’s not a no, and it seems as though Ackles is confident that the phone call will come when it’s time to reconnect with Russell and his storyline. 

    Fans may remember that Russell’s absence isn’t going to be too suspicious to Colter, as his brother typically peels off until his presence is needed again. 

    And in the Tracker Season 3 finale, Russell learns a shocking secret about something his father, Ashton Shaw, may have done to Colter as a child (apparently, that Colter doesn’t even know about), which stops him from killing the man in charge of the Chrono Stasis project. Instead, he makes a secret deal, accepting a dangerous assignment from the leader to protect his brother, telling Reenie to make sure Colter doesn’t come looking for him. 

    Naturally, this buys Russell some time, but ensures that we’ll see him again down the line once he wraps up his mission and returns to help his brother out with whatever case he may need. 

    And the fact that a major change is coming to Tracker Season 4 also means that it may be easier for Ackles to guest-star on the series more frequently, as the storyline allows, considering production is moving from Canada to Los Angeles. 

    Hartley is still the star of the show, but there’s no denying that the brotherly dynamic elevates the entertainment factor. The stakes are higher when the two of them have to navigate working together.

     

    Continue Reading

    Trending